Skip to main content

Measuring Progress Without a Scale


When you set up goals for yourself, how do you measure progress? I imagine that it varies depending on the goal. It likely often includes some sort of number, like a dollar amount, a certain weight at the gym, a certain distance for running, etc.

As a personal trainer, one thing I've noticed is that clients will set goals that include phrases like, "become healthier," "live a healthier lifestyle," "become healthier for my family." However, they almost all have very specific numbers in their minds that will equal those achievements. Usually it's a specific weight goal. Reaching x pounds on the scale somehow equates to being healthier. 

So then it makes sense that, for many people, you measure your progress by stepping on a scale. If the number goes in the direction you want, that's success. If it doesn't, that's failure. But scales lie my friends. And yes, sometimes I have to remind myself of that fact as well. Are you sure your scale is 100% accurate? Don't we almost all believe the doctor's scales are somehow wrong? 

And what about those fancy scales that measure BMI, body fat percent, even water weight? Where do those calculations come from? How accurate are they? I actually came across one article that suggested that most scales don't accurately show a percent fat change for weight loss that is approximately 5 pounds or less. 

What I find a bit funny is that even if we aren't math whizzes somehow we still like numbers. Numbers seem more tangible. More definite, scientific perhaps. But why do we trust numbers more than we trust how we actually look and feel? Especially if those numbers aren't truly showing the whole picture? 

So how are you to measure progress when you're wanting to track weight loss? 


First off, my suggestion is: don't focus on weight. Yes, you do need to know weight for certain calculations like body fat and caloric intake needs. But it's important to not get hung up on that number and determine your success or failure based solely on that number. 

I suggest to focus on losing body fat and increasing lean muscle mass. This is done with a plan that includes resistance and cardio training and proper nutrition. 

If a client tells me they "only" lost x pounds, but I check their body fat percentage and that's gone down and their lean muscle mass has increased, I call that a success, progress. The truth of the matter is, you can weigh more but have less fat. Again, the number on the scale doesn't define the big picture. 

If your body fat percent is down, you're looking fitter, your clothes are fitting better but you weigh the same, how is that not progress? Just because someone weights x pounds doesn't mean they're in shape. Someone can weight 125 but have excess body fat. That's not healthy, that's not progress.  That's just a number on the scale, again, not telling the entire story.  

I think progress for fitness and health can be measured in many ways that do not at all include the number on a scale (this is certainly not a full list).



How do you measure progress?

Comments

  1. Never trust a scale! We'll not never but I agree, it's not the tell all for weight loss. My clothes are always a good indicator of how my body is doing. Waistband a little tight? Most likely too much indulging.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Plantar Fasciitis Woes & Way to Go Wednesday Shout Outs

I wanted to thank everyone again for your many congratulations on completing and getting a PR at my recent half marathon. The support and words mean so much to me.

My legs feel absolutely fine after the race. I could have run yesterday if it weren't for my left foot. So right now I'm trying to heal my left foot. I mentioned that I've been having problems with plantar fasciitis in that foot and that it was the cause of much pain during the race. Since the race, I've been unable to walk on it very well. Lots of hobbling going on.

I've been icing it and trying to keep it elevated. But, I noticed that it's started to get some bruising, not horrible, but worrisome. Not sure if it's better or worse for it to be discolored vs red and swollen. However, this could be indicitive of a tear.
But, my bigger concern with the bruising is that indication that there's been bleeding. Being on Xarelto for the blood clot means my blood doesn't clot very well these days…

PJs n Pizza Recap

What Happened Last Night?
This morning I woke up first at 6:20 when Maddie decided she wanted out of her kennel and to be downstairs. The second time was 8:09 when Heath decided he wanted out of his kennel and downstairs to eat. I won't like, I would like to (needed to) have slept another two hours. It was a little slow going after last night.

Sign of a good party would be my first tweet of the day:  I'm thinking there is a bird in the house...what the hell happened last night???

Yep, found bird poop where bird poop most definitely should not be. Still have not found said bird however.

It should go without saying that last night was a total blast. It was so fun having everyone just be relaxed and comfy in jammies. I am not known for letting loose often, but I definitely went with it last night. There was a bit (lot) of wine consumed, pizza devoured and even some dancing.












Let's Have Coffee

If you're a regular blog reader, I'm sure you've seen similar posts, scenarios if you will, about what we might chat about or what I might say if we sat down and had coffee together.

I think these can be fun. Maybe fun isn't the right word choice exactly. But maybe it is? They're transparent, showing who the blogger really is ... if they're being honest of course. It's not often you truly get to sit down with the person behind the blog.


If we were to have coffee together ...

I would first let you know that I'm not a super fan of coffee. I drink mine with hot cocoa and it's mostly out of habit rather than the need for caffeine. I could forgo it on the weekends entirely.

Since we're talking coffee, I would also let you know that I've never ordered coffee from Starbucks and only once from a true coffee shop. I've only been into 2 Starbucks shops - the original in Seattle and one in town where I ordered a bottle of tea when meeting a friend. …